A Brief Study on the Legitimacy of the National Security Act Examined through the Case of Cheongju SPY RING

By. Hoyeun Youn Views. 1678


Purpose: In this study, the Cheongju Spy Ring incident offers a clear answer for the question of “Are there still spies?” in some parts of our society. It confirms the fact that North Korea is continuously carrying out espionage in South Korea regardless of the situation between the North and South Koreas. Hence, it is intended to discuss the legitimacy of the National Security Act, which is faced with the possibility of repealment, and the ripple effect of its repealment via an actual analysis of the Cheongju Spy Ring incident.

Method: This study examines the legitimacy of the National Security Act and its ripple effects when it is repealed by analyzing the Cheongju Spy Ring incident. It will examine the differences of opinion on the controversy over the existence of the National Security Act to date. The content analytical method and the literature analytical method were implemented comprehensively and specifically for the contents of various aspects of the incident.

Results: Concerning the enactment and repealment of the National Security Act, it is necessary to respond with a clear awareness from the perspective of national security and the maintenance and development of the liberal democratic system. The National Security Act has the purpose to guarantee the people's freedom and human rights by restricting anti-state activities which undermine the national security, not anti-unification-anti-democratic-anti-civil evil laws as North Korea claims. Furthermore, as evident in foreign cases, it can learned that the law is by no means a strong law.

Conclusion: In conclusion, when the National Security Act is repealed, then first, from the security and military perspective, it would be impossible to punish the North Korean spies and the anti-state activists. Second, in terms of the political aspect, political instability will be aggravated by the conflicts between the ruling party pushing for the repealment of the National Security Act and the opposition party opposing thereto, which will further lead to the political instability and social disturbance. Third, in terms of the social aspect, the conflicts between the left and the right wings over the enactment and repealment of the National Security Act will intensify, and the division of public opinion and social unrest will further expand at best. Fourth, the political instability is expected given the increased conflicts among relevant departments within the government. Fifth, in terms of the inter-Korean relations, the federal unification drive after the repealtment of the National Security Act by the North will be a prerequisite for improving the inter-Korean relations, thereby growing the pressure on South Korea. Ultimately, the repealment of the National Security Act will undermine the constitutional system of the Republic of Korea by threatening and destroying not only the security of the Republic of Korea but also the basic order of liberal democracy in the political, economic, and social areas.

[Keywords] Cheongju Spy Ring, National Security Act, National Security, Anti-Government Organization, Spy in South Korea


[8] Kim HJ. Proposals for the Revision of Laws to Execute Punishment on Spies of Foreign Nationality. Hankuk University of Foreign Studies Law Review, 40(1), 61-80 (2016).
[15] Youn JO. The First Incident of the People’s Revolutionary Party and Do Ye-jong’s Activities. Daegu Sahak, 133, 315-357 (2018).
[18] Huh BS. Representation of the Divided Diaspora and Zainichi Korean Spies. Journal of Dong-ak Language and Literature, 73, 19-141 (2017).
[19] Choi JD. Corona Pandemic Period, Changes in the International Order and Russia’s Diplomatic Strategies: Focusing on Sino-Russian, U.S.-Russian Relations. Journal of Eurasian Studies, 44(3), 49-85 (2020).
[23] Yoon HS. Strengthening the Capacity of Law Enforcement Agency in Line with the New Security Situation. International Journal of Justice & Law, 1(1), 1-6 (2016). [Article]
[24] Lee HJ. Review on National Security Oriented Judicial System of Republic of Korea. International Journal of Justice & Law, 1(1), 18-24 (2016). [Article]
[25] Yang JC & Lee KM. Review of Trend Analysis of Terrorism and Korea's Implications. International Journal of Terrorism & National Security, 5(1), 40-47 (2020).  [Article]
[26] Kim TM & Park HY. Characteristics of Legal System Related to Security in Republic of Korea. International Journal of Protection & Investigation, 2(1), 25-32 (2017). [Article]
[27] Jo SG. The Policies of South Korea's Counter Intelligence Agency on North Korea's Espionage Activities in South Korea. International Journal of Protection, Security & Investigation, 3(2), 30-35 (2018). [Article]
[28] Hoh IT. Justification for Repealing the National Security Act. Korean Journal of Criminology, 16(1), 237-274 (2004).
[29] Kim YK. T Factors Influencing on Public Attitude about Maintenance or Abolition of National Security Law. Humanities, Social Sciences and Technology Convergence Society, 8(11), 513-522 (2018).
[30] Park WS. A Study on the Improvement System of National Counter-intelligence Activities. International Journal of Military Affairs, 6(1), 45-58 (2021). [Article]
[31] Park SS. A Study on the Abuse and Interpretation of the Article(7) of National Security Act. The Joumal of Law, 21(4), 1-30 (2013).
[32] Lee KS. Stop the Conspiracy to Open and Close the National Security Act: The Focus of the Strategy for Redemption against South Korea is the Abolition of the Security Law and the Withdrawal of U.S. Forces. Monthly Korea Forum, 116(1), 94-101 (1999).
[33] Son DK. The 1st East-Asia International Symposium -Reforms of Criminal Justice System: The Arranging Measures of the Substantial Criminal Acts on the Ideological Offender-. Korean Journal of Comparative Criminal Law, 8(1), 245-265 (2006).
[34] Lee HJ. Special lssue: Critical lssues in the So-called Wangjaesan Case; Application of the Hearsay Rule in the Cases of National Security Law. Democracy Law Research Society, 49, 41-70 (2012).
[35] Chae SJ. A Study on the Necessity of Maintaining National Security Law. Dankook Law Review, 41(3), 91-123 (2017).
[36] Chae SJ. A Study on the Policy Path Change in the National Security Law according to the Historical Institutionalism. Journal of Northeast Asian Studies, 22(2), 239-261 (2017).
[37] Jo SG. Terrorism Crisis on Northeast Asia. International Journal of Crisis & Safety, 5(1), 35-42 (2020).  [Article]
[38] Jhe SH. The Consept and Scope of Anti-state Organization under the Korean National Security Law. Korean Lawyers Association, 59(8), 5-52 (2010).
[39] Khae SJ. A Study on the Policy Path Change in the National Security Law according to the Historical Institutionalism. Korea Northeast Asian Rice Federation, 22(2), 239-261 (2017).
[40] Jung KS. Articles: Internationalization of Human Rights Campaign against the National Security Law: It`s Accomplishments and Further Tasks. Democratic Law, 33, 199-227 (2007).
[41] Oh DS. Democracy and Human Rights in Prof. Song Du-yul Case; The Current Issues on the NSL and the Constitutionality of the Law for the NSL Abolition. Democratic Law, 26, 105-130 (2004).
[42] Kim TS. Validity of Security Law Application to the 3.1(March 1st) Movement. Korean Journal of Comparative Criminal Law, 21(1), 235-256 (2019).
[43] Kim HJ. Changes in Statutes on Political Associations in Daehan Empire from the Perspective of Constitutional History. Gyeongsang National University Law Institute, 25(3), 41-63 (2017).

[1] https://www.dynews.co.kr/ (2021).
[2] https://www.ohmynews.com/ (2021).
[3] https://www.edaily.co.kr/ (2021).
[4] https://www.hankyung.com/ (2021).
[5] https://www.hani.co.kr/ (2021).
[6] https://www.segye.com/ (2021).
[7] https://www.Pennmike.com/ (2021).
[9] https://www.weekly.chosu.com/ (2021).
[10] https://www.Naeil.com/ (2021).
[11] https://www.Newsis.com/ (2021).
[12] https://www.pressian.com/ (2021).
[13] https://www.monthly.chosun.com/ (2021).
[14] https://www.new1.kr/ (2021).
[16] https://www.newstomato.com/ (2021).
[17] https://www.newdaily.co.kr/ (2021).
[20] https://www.inews365.com/ (2021).
[21] https://www.Munhwa.com/ (2021).
[22] https://www.Chosun.com/ (2021).

? Source: joongang.co.kr