Directions for the Introduction of a Horizontal Fiscal Equalization System for the PROTECTION of Financially Lagging Area ..

Abstract

Purpose: The purpose of this study is to address the horizontal fiscal imbalance caused by the financial decentralization of local governments in Korea, and propose a direction for the introduction of the horizontal fiscal equalization system for the protection of financially lagging area.

Method: To achieve the purpose of this study, the primary details of the first phase of financial decentralization were confirmed based on the theory of the financially lagging area and the horizontal mediation system. Furthermore, the regional synergistic development fund, which is a similar system currently implemented, and the direction of its introduction, were examined.

Results: As a result of the study, first, the fact the regional balanced distribution is very much needed through the protection of financially lagging area and the regional solidarity was confirmed. Second, to introduce the horizontal fiscal equalization system, it is necessary to provide a direction for the introduction of the system which may achieve a basic agreement among the local governments, which are direct stakeholders. Third, the form of the system is introduced as a fund, and an expansionary system’s development plan based on the existing regional synergistic development fund system may be considered. Fourth, it is necessary to use the local consumption tax in terms of adequacy and stability of the financial resources and relaxing the tax revenue imbalance between the local governments in connection with the fiscal decentralization. Fifth, as for the distribution index, it is necessary to use to the farthest extent possible the variables related to population, population characteristics, per capita income, and area, which are among the variables beyond the control of local governments. Sixth, it is necessary for the principal of management to secure a sufficient size for the local government for spending the financial resources.

Conclusion: The horizontal fiscal equalization system ought to, first, pursue a comprehensive development of balance for the region, and second, aim to address the gap in financial power between the regions, and third, be introduced in the form of complementing the vertical financial mediation.

[Keywords] Financial Decentralization, Horizontal Fiscal Equalization System, Protection of Financially Lagging Area, Regional Synergistic Development Fund, Regional Solidarity

---

References

[1] Cho BH. A Study on the Role of Local Adjustment Grant in the Inter-governmental Fiscal Relation-ship. The Korean Association for Local Government Studies, 22(4), 157-183 (2019).
[2] Han JM & Choi JS. Proposals for Tax Assignment between Provincial and Local Governments: Considering Fiscal Decentralization Policies. The Korea Journal of Local Public Finance, 25(1), 33-71 (2020).
[3] Moon JJ & Hong KY. A Study on the Tax Source Adjustment Plan of National and Local Taxes for Refining Local Finance. Journal of Tax Studies, 20(4), 179-200 (2020).
[4] Lim SS. Effects and Implications of Moon Jae-in Government’s First-phase Fiscal Decentralization on Incheon’s Revenue. Urban Research, 18, 223-260 (2020).
[5] Kim SJ & Yoon TS. A Study on the Improvement Plans to Local Finance Mediation System Accord-ance with Changes in Local Fiscal Environment: Focusing on the Role of Local Finance Mediation System. Institute of Public Policy & Administration, 34(3), 29-52 (2020).
[6] Kim TS & Lee JB. Analysis of Perception of Naturopathy Convergence and Utilization Satisfaction Perceived by Skin Beauty Industry Workers. Protection Convergence, 5(2), 94-102 (2020). [Article]
[7] Kim JY & Lee JB. Direction of Smart Healthcare Utilization in Korea's Non-medical Healthcare Ser-vice Area. Regulations, 6(2), 34-43 (2021). [Article]
[8] Kwon SA & Ryu SI. Measures for Strengthening Performance of Disaster and Safety Management System at Local Government. International Journal of Human & Disaster, 4(1), 1-7 (2019).  [Article]
[9] Ha HJ & Lee JB & Lee OR & Hwang G & Park SR & Kwon HJ & Kim SS. Search for SNB-program Par-ticipation Experience and Constituent Factors for Health Intervention: Using the Colaizzi Method. International Journal of Crisis & Safety, 5(2), 66-73 (2020). [Article]
[10] Park KB. A Study on the Establish of Continuous and Long-term National Disaster Situation Sce-nario. International Journal of Human & Disaster, 6(2), 39-49 (2021). [Article]
[11] Sa YJ. Human Capital Management Crisis for Indefinite-term Contract Workers in Local Govern-ment: Focusing on Education & Training and Performance. International Journal of Crisis & Safety, 5(1), 1-12 (2020). [Article]
[12] Jeong JH & Ju HJ. The Analysis of Change Process of Infectious Diseases Management System and Implications in China. The Korean Association for Comparative Government, 22(4), 99-125 (2018).
[13] Son WB & Park YH. Crisis Management and Leadership of the Local Government in the Covid-19 Disaster: A Case Study of Gyeonggi Province. Gyeonggi Research Institute Review, 22(2), 1-25 (2020).
[15] Lee JW. Fiscal Decentralization, Fiscal Conflicts, and the Conditions for Promoting Horizontal Fiscal Equalization System toward State. The Korea Journal of Local Public Finance, 25(3), 33-61 (2020).
[16] Kim YC. A Study on the Balanced Regional Development Strategy through the Horizontal Equali-zation Development Fund Ⅱ. Journal of the Korean Geographical Society, 43(6), 914-937 (2008).
[19] Hwang HD. A Study on the Stickiness of the Intergovernmental Fiscal Coordination System: Fo-cused on the Objectivity and Simplicity of the Allocation Formula. Journal of Local Government Studies, 33(2), 53-91 (2021).
[20] Kim ST. Fiscal Equalization based on the Shared-tax Revenue in Korea. The Korean Journal of Local Government Studies, 19(2), 247-271 (2015).
[21] Cho KH. A Study on the SGA Grant Using Gini Coefficient Decomposition Method: Focusing on Abolition of Priority Distribution System and Change of Allocation Standard. The Korea Journal of Local Public Finance, 23(2), 179-206 (2018).
[22] Kwon KD & Cho JY & Cho KJ & Lee KW. A Study on Sustainability of Coexistent Local Development Fund: Focused on Comparison between Metropolitan and Non-metropolitan Area. Institute of Public Policy & Administration, 31(4), 367-394 (2017).
[23] Kim TY & Park KH. A Study on the Collaborative Fiscal Governance Model in Korea: An Alternative of Redistributing the Local Consumption Tax Revenue among Local Governments. The Korea Journal of Local Public Finance, 18(3), 61-89 (2013).
[24] Han JM & Lee SH & Kim KM & Lee SI. Improvements of Performance Management of the Fund for Mutual Development of Municipalities in Korea. The Korea Journal of Local Public Finance, 26(1), 153-196 (2021).
[25] Sohn HJ. Restructuring the Fiscal Assignment System between the Central and Local Governments for Fiscal Decentralization. Korean Governance Review, 15(2), 157-185 (2008).
[26] Choi JE & Jeon JS & Jin JB. The Effects of the Financial Adjustment System on the Equity. The Korea Journal of Local Public Finance, 23(2), 151-177 (2018).
[27] Cho MK & Kim Y. The Impact of Fiscal Decentralization on Regional Economic Growth. Journal of the Korean Urban Management Association, 27(2), 263-286 (2014).
[28] Bok MS. An Analysis on Improvement of Horizontal Equity by Vertical Financial Adjustment: In Aspect of the Changes of Gini Coefficient. The Korean Association for Local Government & Admin-istration Studies, 30(3), 73-94 (2016).
[29] Park BH. A Scheme to Improve Equity among Local Government Revenue in Intergovernmental Fiscal Coordination System. The Korea Journal of Local Public Finance, 23(2), 111-149 (2018).
[30] Lee SB. A Study on Improvement Strategy of Uppertier and Lowertier Local Governments’ Mu-nicipal/Provincial Subsidy System. Korean Local Government Law Association, 19(4), 165-195 (2019).

---

[14] Lim Sl. A Study on the Introduction of the Horizontal Fiscal Equalization System. Korea Institute of Local Finance Report (2018).
[17] Song JY & Park SY & Kim SK. A Study on the Feasibility Evaluation Method for Local Investment Projects Considering Balanced Regional Development. The Korea Research Institute for Local Administration (2019).
[18] Ministry of the Interior and Safety. Summary of Local Budget for Fiscal Year(Ⅰ) (2021).



? Source: economist.co.kr